HOWTO: Loan Audits and Qualified Attorneys

Contributed by Rob Harrington
co-founder, LoanChex, Inc.

I basically got into the loan audit business as a means to save my properties. As a small-fish RE investor, I was able to retire in 2005, only to wake up in 2007 and find I was possibly going to lose everything. I started the same way many of you are starting–by researching the fraud in my own two WAMU loans. My Florida nightmare had begun.

A few weeks ago, after 2 and 1/2 years of pure hell, fear, misery, frustration…. (sound familiar…?) opposing counsel and whoever purported to “own my loan” failed to show up to the hearing. The hearing was to show cause as to why the Judge’s direct order to compel discovery was not followed. That is a no-no with Judges. It shows disrespect to the Judge, the court, and to justice and fairness. And my case was dismissed… for now.

As co-founder of a Mortgage Fraud Examination firm, I have talked to many of the best auditors in the country. Here is what you should consider before you spend more money towards your legal defense of your home.

1. Only get a loan audit if you are under direct supervision of a qualified foreclosure defense attorney. Your counsel will better determine the scope of work of the audit. I urge new auditors to work ONLY under Attorney supervision and NEVER directly be paid by the homeowner. The rationale behind my humble opinion is that history repeats itself. The Attorney Generals will soon be coming after the auditors as they did the loan mod types for many good reasons. Many auditors will be coming over from the loan mod business now that they are getting shut down. This industry will become “infested.”
2. Don’t buy an audit directly from an auditing firm. You may fall into the same problem that many struggling homeowners did over the last few years when hiring a loan mod company. Loan audits are very time consuming. Audits need to be exact and precise, and direct counsel to which laws are effected by breaking down the loan origination, underwriting, appraisal, closing documents, disclosures, pooling and service agreements, escrow accounts, payment histories… and the list goes on and on, ad nauseum.
3. Beware of simple TILA/RESPA software audits. They can be easily manipulated and biased if data is not entered correctly. My partner Dave is a 15-year mortgage expert who can tear a loan apart backwards and forwards. He is emphatic that you need to find fraud and serious errors to build good pleadings, effective affirmative defenses, and viable counter-suits. Additionally, focus on securitization/ownership issues and fraudulent assignments. That’s the meaty stuff! A simple TILA/RESPA is only a small fraction of the audit process, as well, the full audit cannot be performed until after full discovery. Your attorney and auditor will work better with a collaborative approach to building your proper defense. In other words, there are far better ways to ensure better results in court. A nationally prominent examiner describes a basic TILA/RESPA audit as a “band-aid on an amputation.” Spending $300 – $499 on a TILA/RESPA audit (over the internet?) will only limit the strength of your case. Your investment may be a waste of money. When it comes to YOUR case, “why bring a knife to a gun fight?”
4. Hold your attorney accountable and responsible for the audit’s content. Great attorneys win more cases than bad attorneys. Your attorney should be the key to increasing the odds of your success. Otherwise, why are you paying them to take on a losing case that they knew you would never win?
5. And your biggest question? How much? A comprehensive audit will average around $1500 to $2500. Ouch! I humanely suggest that the audit process can evolve over a long period of time and best compliments and supplements your attorneys work as your case evolves. Discovery may take a year or longer (as it did in my personal foreclosure case.) If your case gets dismissed earlier than the discovery phase, then you would never have paid the entire cost anyways with a phased-in metered approach. Your attorney should always explain the process and expense to you. More and more attorneys are starting to create creative billing systems for homeowners in today’s market. They oftentimes will take foreclosure cases with small down payments and reasonable monthly fees. If you already have been forced to stop paying your mortgage, IT MIGHT BE CHEAPER TO LITIGATE ON A MONTHLY BASIS THAN TO PAY RENT, OR A MORTGAGE PAYMENT, ON THE SAME MONTHLY BASIS. Additionally, set a flat fee for scope of work to include all work through discovery obtainment and analysis. This “caps” your high end of your legal investment so that you are not taking some crazy ride in a taxi from hell. This also helps you budget your expenses. Drastic times demand creative solutions. Demand creative payment solutions from your attorney. If they won’t, someone else will. Their ranks are growing by the day to meet the demand.

In fairness to foreclosure defense attorneys, today’s litigation defense is not as cut and dry as any of us would like to see it. Yet, case law is being made almost daily. Judges and attorneys alike are starting to see that loans made in the last ten years are a lot different than in earlier banking history. Securitization, exotic loan products, insane underwriting practices, lack of regulatory oversight, criminality, and pure greed, creates a different slant to today’s legal issues.

This is why it is crucial to hire an attorney who has been specially-trained in foreclosure defense [Editor's Note: You can find such attorneys through our site, IamFacingForeclosure.com]. This special rare breed should be an expert in contract law, real estate law, finance law and securities law, due to the overwhelmingly complex nature of this decade’s loans. Now you know WHY, in 2009, MILLIONS of (non-attorney) consumers are in foreclosure today!

By 2010, get ready for 3 more years of the exploding “Option Arms!” As lending insiders have famously stated, “Option Arms” are like neutron bombs…. kills the people but leaves the buildings standing.” Thanks guys!! See y’all in court!

So in the final analysis, hire the right attorney first–deal with the audit later!

Relax and keep the faith! I know of four foreclosure dismissals this last few weeks. The odds are tipping in your favor!

Rob Harrington
co-founder
LoanChex, Inc.
(850) 259-6422

PS – I am NOT an attorney. No information that I share should be construed as legal advice. Always consult with a qualified foreclosure defense attorney regarding your foreclosure. (I am only a ticked-off, entrepreneurial homeowner who stands for property rights, free speech, due process, justice, and fairness in the USA.)